How to Choose a Primary KPI for a Game Feature
Choose a game feature’s primary KPI from the player behavior you want to change. For a challenge meant to bring new players back after their first win, next-day return among eligible players is a direct starting point.
A daily challenge can make a game busier without addressing the problem the team set out to solve. Before choosing a feature, name the player behavior you want to change and where it occurs in the lifecycle.

Turn the idea into a testable hypothesis
If new players rarely return after their first session, a challenge might give them a reason to come back the next day. That points to day-two return as a possible primary measure. If the goal is more sessions among established players, the audience and measurement window will be different.
Agree on the decision before shipping
Pick one primary KPI, set a threshold for a meaningful change, and identify supporting measures. A daily challenge might improve return frequency while hurting completion of the onboarding flow. Decide how you would interpret that trade-off and whether an always-on feature or a limited event makes the better test.
Find the point where players lose a reason to return
Before building a daily challenge, split first-session players by the last meaningful action they completed. Someone who left before finishing the tutorial may need clearer instructions. Someone who completed the tutorial, won a match, and still never returned may need a goal for the next session. Showing both players the same challenge makes it harder to learn which problem you solved.
For the second group, try a small test. After the first win, show eligible players a challenge they can complete on a later visit. Randomly assign eligible players before they see it and measure next-day return across everyone assigned, including those who never open the challenge. Comparing only people who clicked will favor those who were already more engaged.
Decide what you would do with the result
Suppose more players return the next day, but the follow-up shows that the extra visits mostly end immediately after claiming the reward. Check whether the challenge led players into the intended mode and whether they came back again after it ended. If it generated a claim without helping players find something worth returning to, change the challenge objective before building a permanent calendar.



